Understanding Property Division in Divorce: Who Gets the House?

Divorce can be a difficult and emotional process, especially when it comes to dividing up property. While it’s not the most exciting topic to discuss, understanding property division in divorce is essential for couples who are splitting up.

This article will provide an overview of the laws related to who gets the house in a divorce and what each party should expect when it comes to property division. With this information, you’ll be better equipped to protect your legal rights and get through this challenging time as smoothly as possible. Let’s dive into understanding property division and who gets the house in a divorce.

What is Marital Property?

Marital property is an important concept in family law. It refers to any assets or debts acquired by either spouse during the marriage, regardless of whose name is on the title or account. In the event of a divorce or legal separation, the court will typically divide marital property between the two parties.

Understanding what constitutes marital property and how it differs from separate property is important for anyone going through a divorce or contemplating marriage. To have a clear understanding of what to expect, examples of marital property can include a wide range of items:

  • Real estate, including the marital home, vacation homes, and rental properties
  • Bank accounts, including checking, savings, and investment accounts
  • Retirement accounts, such as 401(k)s and IRAs
  • Vehicles, including cars, boats, and planes
  • Personal property, such as furniture, jewelry, and artwork
  • Business interests, including ownership stakes in partnerships or corporations

In addition to physical items, it also includes any debt taken on by either spouse during the marriage, including credit card debt, loans, or medical bills.  When couples get divorced, they must divide their marital property between them according to state laws. Generally speaking, all income earned and all assets obtained during the marriage are considered marital property regardless of whose name may be on the title or deed.

Distinguishing Between Marital and Separate Property

The ability to distinguish between marital and separate property is crucial. Separate property is any assets or debts acquired before the marriage. This also includes gifts received during the marriage or inheritance that was kept separate from marital funds. This type of property should not be divided upon divorce and typically remains with whoever holds title or ownership.

In general, separate property is not subject to division in a divorce. However, there are some exceptions to this rule, such as when separate property transformers into marital property through commingling. Commingling of marital and separate property means mixing the properties till they are unable to be separated.

Factors That Affect Property Division

It’s important to understand that each state follows different laws when it comes to this, but other factors at play can determine how the division takes place. Here’s an overview of five key factors that could influence property division in a divorce.

balanced law concept

State Laws

Every state has its own set of rules when it comes to dividing up property in a divorce settlement. These laws often take into consideration the length of the marriage, contributions made by each spouse, and their respective incomes.

Depending on where you live, certain items may be considered separate or community property, with some exceptions. It’s important to familiarize yourself with your state laws when it comes to dividing assets in a divorce.

Length of the Marriage

The longer you’ve been married, the more likely it is that property division will be split equally between both spouses. In some states, marriages lasting 10 or more years are considered long-term and divided 50/50, while shorter marriages may not get an equal property division.

Income and Earning Potential of Each Spouse

This factor can play an important role in the division of assets during a divorce settlement. Generally speaking, if one spouse earns significantly more than the other, they may be expected to pay higher alimony or provide more assets from the marriage for their ex.

Contributions to the Marriage

When it comes to the division of assets, many states also consider each spouse’s contributions to the marriage. This includes any investments or money put towards a home that was shared by both spouses during their marriage, such as furniture and appliances.

Health and Age of Each Spouse

Age and health can also be taken into consideration when deciding who gets what in a divorce settlement. Generally speaking, older spouses are more likely to get a larger portion of the property division because they may not have much time left in life to accumulate wealth or resources on their own. Similarly, if one spouse has health issues that limit their ability to find gainful employment after divorce, they may also receive a larger portion of the property division.

How Property is Divided in Divorce

There are several methods for dividing property in divorce, and the approach used will depend on the laws of the state and the circumstances of the couple. In most cases, courts will use the equitable distribution approach to divide marital property. However, in certain states, community property laws may apply. It’s important to understand both approaches and which factors influence a court’s decision when it comes to dividing up the couple’s shared assets.

divorce agreement

Equitable Distribution

The most common method for dividing property in a divorce is equitable distribution. In this approach, assets and debts are divided fairly, but not necessarily equally. The goal is to ensure that each spouse receives a fair share of the property.

Under an equitable distribution approach, each spouse is required to provide full and accurate disclosure of their assets and debts. Once this information has been shared, the couple can negotiate a settlement agreement that outlines how their property will be divided.

If they are unable to reach an agreement, a judge will make the final determination. The court considers many factors, such as:

  • contributions made by each spouse towards acquiring or increasing the value of the marital assets and liabilities
  • duration of the marriage
  • age and health of each spouse
  • need for a separate residence or economic support from one partner
  • sources of income for each spouse
  • current and future earning potential of each spouse
  • tax consequences for each spouse
  • premarital agreement (if any)
  • other relevant factors

Community Property States

In some states, the property is divided using a community property approach. Nine states follow the community property system when it comes to marital property division in a divorce:

  • Arizona
  • California
  • Idaho
  • Louisiana
  • Nevada
  • New Mexico
  • Texas
  • Washington
  • Wisconsin

In such cases, all assets acquired by either partner during the marriage are considered jointly owned by both spouses. In Alaska, couples can opt into a community property system by signing a community property agreement. This means that the property must be divided in half when a couple divorces. Therefore if one party acquires more than 50% of the shared assets during the marriage, then he or she will have to defer some of their shares to their former partner upon divorce.

Factors Influencing Property Division

Regardless of the method used, several factors can influence property division during a divorce. Besides the above-mentioned ones, other factors can include:

  • The presence of a prenuptial agreement
  • The living standard established during the marriage
  • The tax consequences of property division
  •  Need for separate residence or economic support from one partner
  • Tax consequences for each spouse

In general, the goal of property division in divorce is to ensure that each spouse receives a fair share of the property, based on the unique circumstances of the couple. While it can be challenging to divide property in divorce, working with an experienced family law attorney can help you navigate the process and negotiate a fair settlement.

Who Gets the House in Divorce?

When a couple divorces, one of the most significant assets to divide is the family home. Deciding who gets the house can be a contentious and emotional issue, especially if there are children involved. So, who gets the house in a divorce with children?

The decision on how to divide the house will depend on several factors. In this section, we will explore some of the factors that influence who keeps the house in a divorce, the options for dividing the house, and examples of court cases involving property division.

Factors Influencing Who Gets the House

Who gets the house in a divorce is influenced by some of the following factors:

  • Who purchased the house: If one spouse owned the home before the marriage, they may have a stronger claim to the property.
  • Contribution to the mortgage payments: If one spouse has made more significant contributions to the mortgage payments or renovations, they may have a stronger claim to the property.
  • Custody of children: If one spouse is awarded custody of the children, they may be more likely to receive the family home to provide stability for the children.
  • Financial situation: If one spouse cannot afford to buy or maintain the family home, they may be more likely to relinquish the property to the other spouse.

house property

Possibilities For Dividing the House

There are several possibilities that can lead to dividing the house during a divorce settlement. These include:

  • Buyout: One spouse can buy out the other spouse’s share of the property. This can be accomplished through refinancing the mortgage to remove the other spouse’s name from the loan.
  • Sale: The house can be sold, and the proceeds can be divided between spouses. This may be necessary if neither spouse can afford to keep the property or if they cannot agree on a fair buyout price.
  • Co-ownership: In some cases, both spouses may decide to continue owning the property jointly, even after the divorce is finalized. They may be able to come up with an arrangement that allows both spouses access to their marital home for different periods. This may be the case if there are children involved and both parents would like to spend equal amounts of time living in the home with them.

High-Profile Court Cases Involving Property Division

There have been several high-profile court cases involving property division during a divorce settlement. One example is the divorce of billionaire hedge fund manager Ken Griffin and his ex-wife, Anne Dias. The couple’s settlement included the transfer of several properties, including the Manhattan penthouse, to Ken Griffin. Since they had a prenup, Dias was entitled to $1 million for each year they were married and she got an extra $22.5 million payment. Anne Dias received custody of their children as well.

Another example is the divorce of Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos and his ex-wife, Mackenzie Scott. The couple’s settlement involved the transfer of 25% of Jeff Bezos’s Amazon stock, worth $36 billion, to Mackenzie Scott. They also divided several properties where Scott got their Beverly Hills mansion.

Special Circumstances

Certain special circumstances may complicate matters when looking for ways to divide the property. To ensure your rights and assets are protected during the process, familiarizing yourself with these situations can be beneficial.

Prenuptial Agreements

A prenuptial agreement is a contract between two parties entering into a marriage that sets out their respective financial rights in the event of a future divorce or death. These agreements address issues such as division of property, spousal support, and inheritance rights among others.

In some cases, these agreements can override state laws governing the division of marital property upon divorce. It’s important to note that prenups must meet certain criteria and be signed before you tie the knot to be enforced by the court.

Inherited Property

When one spouse inherits property during the marriage, such as a house or other assets, it’s typically considered their separate property and not subject to division in a divorce. However, if they choose to commingle this inherited property with marital assets, such as investing into a joint bank account or taking out a mortgage on the inherited home in both of their names, then it can become subject to division upon divorce.

Business Ownership

If you were co-owner of a business before getting married or became a business partner during your marriage, then any profits made by that business are also liable for division upon divorce. It’s important to have an experienced attorney review any existing business ownership contracts and advise you on the relevant laws when it comes to dividing business assets in a divorce.

Wrapping Up

Understanding property division during a divorce is a complex process that should be handled with care and consideration. The main takeaway from this article is that who gets the house in a divorce will depend on state law and your specific financial situation such as assets, debts, and other properties held by both parties.

If you are unsure of what to do when it comes to dividing marital property during a divorce, seek advice from a legal expert. We also recommend discussing potential scenarios with your spouse beforehand so that you can come up with an equitable split without having to go through the court system.

Divorce doesn’t have to be all doom and gloom. With thoughtful planning, it can be an opportunity for both parties to start fresh without too much disruption or disappointment.

About the Author

Scroll to Top